Wednesday, December 21, 2011

Higher Education in Kerala - Bodhigram Seminar

Venue: Bodhigram Center, Thuvayoor South, Pathanamthitta Dt., Kerala
Date: December 20, 2011
Organized by John Samuel

Moderator: Ambassador TP Sreenivasan (TPS), Chairman, Kerala Higher Education Council
Speakers:
Dr. TG Arun, Institute for Development Policy and Management, University of Manchester, United Kingdom
Prof. CT Aravinda Kumar, School of Environmental Sciences, Mahatma Gandhi University, Kottayam
Prof. KM Seethi, School of International Relations and Politics, Mahatma Gandhi University, Kottayam

Ambassador TPS

TPS started off with the need to re-assess the answers to fundamental questions concerning education, especially "What is the aim of higher education?". He went on to present several points that could/would help shape the agenda/focus of HEC over the next few years.
  • Focus on Employability: TPS stressed the need for focusing on employability. The current agenda of HEC, he said, would emphasize on creating new courses/programmes that would focus on creating a pool of graduates who are well suited for the job market of the world in the next 5 years. He added that this could help fill the void of courses/programmes in many areas which offer good employment opportunities such as printing technology and anthropology.
  • Creating World-class Universities: Quoting the Shanghai rankings in which the first Indian University (IISc) is ranked in the 301-400 bracket and other rankings that rank Indian Universities on a similar quality, he said that there is a visible need for world class universities. Ensuring more academic freedom and ensuring that there is enough emphasis on research could be ways to move forward.
  • Quality and Quantity: He said that though quality was often sacrificed for the sake of quantity in the Indian higher education scenario, we havent been able to even ensure enough quantity either.
  • Arrival of Foreign Universities: TPS opined that the arrival of foreign universities into the country could provide more opportunities and enough checks have been put in place wrt transfer of funds outside India, and hence, need not be viewed with as much skepticism as it is being viewed now (e.g., Devinder Sharma, among others). This topic, however, was not picked up by later speakers in the discussion.
  • Accountability, Accreditation and Assessment: These were brought up as areas that need improvements. In addition to NAAC, a state-specific Accreditation agency called the SAAC would be setup very soon.
  • Concerns about Reception of Reforms: The HEC is being viewed as yet-another-body by many institutions, and reforms that it has been trying to bring through (during Dr. KN Panikker's tenure) have been opposed by many colleges. This has been a road-block and reform measures need to be aware of such facts. (See this for a news report on higher education reforms during the previous HEC)
  • Industry Interaction: He stressed the need for more debate on how academia can meaningfully interact with the industry in a synergistic manner.
Dr. Arun

Dr. Arun stressed on the Social Sciences education in the state and presented an optimistic view based on recent development such as quality gaining new impetus as a concern under UPA2, and accelerating internal competition being a positive sign for higher education in India. He, however, raised several concerns about the education sector (with focus on social sciences). Some of these are as follows:

  • Is there a remedy to the current situation where professional education is widely viewed as being limited to medicine, engineering and nursing?
  • Why are we not able to create a community that is suited for the new kinds of jobs?
  • Most of our management schools focus on western principles and case studies; for example, there is no study focusing on the Indian experience such as self-help groups.
  • There is an increasing homogeneity of views among social scientists; we should develop an effort to encourage diversity of views, at least in social sciences (where it is most important).
Dr. Arun concluded with a three-point suggestion for the HEC:
  1. State directed policy initiative (e.g., a masterplan or roadmap) is required for higher education in Kerala.
  2. There should be a renewed emphasis on knowledge creation in academia
  3. HEC should monitor global changes in the job market and should develop a dynamic and up-to-date information portal that keeps people in Kerala informed about job prospects for the future.
An interesting academic question raised by Dr. Arun was on the perceived/actual duality of research and teaching. He brought up the question as to whether teaching and research are orthogonal responsibilities of an academic or whether there could be some synergistic relation between the two (perhaps, also thinking aloud as to whether we could invent mechanisms to create a synergy).

Prof. Aravindan [SLIDES]

Prof. Aravindan stressed on the need for quantity improvement in higher education. He said that there is a tremendous opportunity presenting itself before us with the projected improvement in the pan-India higher education enrollment from 12% to 30%. He critiqued the lack of planning in higher education and the premise that economy and education are unrelated. However, the Kerala scenario has been seen to be among the better ones in India, with MGU (h-index = 35) and CUSAT being recognized as among the better universities in India in terms of research output. The not-so-employable nature of certain courses was also brought up for discussion. Prof. Aravindan concluded with a listing of several areas for improvement:

  • Removal of bureaucracy from academics: He said that academia is tremendously bureaucratic and is among the most bureaucratic public institutions.
  • Lack of Manpower: Sanctions of funding need to come with adequate manpower, else, the call for quality cannot be addressed.
  • Need for Transparency in Appoinment
  • Take steps to reduce/remove inbreeding
  • Integrated Masters worth experimenting: The separation between undergraduate and graduate research is often artificial and unproductive.
  • Emphasis on Knowledge Creation (Research) needed
  • Promote (creation of) Centers of Excellence
  • Consortium for research: Inter-college consortia to further research could help alleviate the infrastructural issues.
  • Group Appoinments: The Japan model of appointing faculty groups instead of individual faculty could be worth experimenting with.
  • VC and Syndicate Appoinments.....
Prof. Seethi

Prof. Seethi had a mostly pessimistic view of the current model and stressed on the need for radical action to bring about a qualitative change. He stressed that we are nearing a crisis in Kerala academia and the path forward for HEC would be really tough. He raised several points such as:

  • Politicization: The trend of cleansing the academia of previous government's actions and the call for greater autonomy of educational institutions are at loggerheads.
  • Academia Mediocrity: Kerala's biggest crisis is the mediocrity of academia. This is also a prelude to a larger crisis in the near future.
  • Employability: Prof. Seethi critiqued thew stress on employability (as raised by TPS) by saying that education would be helpful even for those who may eventually not make use of it, in their jobs.
  • Social Sciences: Kerala, as a society, has a unique aversion to Social Sciences. A society that doesnt teach social sciences is sure to go to ruins, and hence, something needs to be done quickly about it.
Remarks

Being my blog, I take the freedom to comment on some things above (while fully understanding that what I think is not one-hundredth as important as the opinions of the eminent speakers above). :)

Was pleasantly surprised that the lack of infrastructure did not come up as a burning issue (as much as I expected). Perhaps, we are doing well on provisioning colleges/universities with adequate infrastructure already - I used to have a view that we, being a poor country/state, could focus on infrastructure-light research areas (such as Computer Science, Mathematics, Statistics, Economics, among others); with infrastructural concerns not being in the center-stage anymore, such as view is less valid.

The education as an enabler or for job is a debate that could go on for ever, and keeps coming up over and again (most recently, in The Educational Lottery); and the obvious thing is that the academicians would line up on the "enabler" side, whereas the policy makers could lean more towards the employability side. Given the vast skilled and unemployed workforce, we definitely do need to focus on employability - however, an all-out approach for employability could lead to sacrificing the knowledge creation goal (since people who study to work, would be less likely to indulge in knowledge creation).

In a casual conversation with Dr. Ajith Kumar (CSES), it was interesting to understand that the traditional metrics of quality for research in science and technology (e.g., h-index) are largely inapplicable for social sciences. For a study on Kerala society, one would unsurprisingly cite papers that relate to Kerala (mostly), and hence, traditional citation based indices for a researcher focusing on Kerala studies would be indicative of the size of the population of the community focusing on Kerala studies (and less indicative of the quality of research). Perhaps, the lack of interest in social science (education and) research is contributed partly to such academic visibility issues? I was also pleasantly surprised to see Kerala's universities being among the forefront in the country in terms of academic indicators (as Prof. Aravindan had pointed out in his talk).

12 comments:

JS Adoor said...

Thanks Deepak for this excellent report. I hope to get the whole report within the next couple of weeks.

deepak said...

Thank you, JS. Looking forward to the comprehensive report from you. In all solidarity to your earnest endeavor in getting people and ideas together towards making change happen.

Anonymous said...

Love is equal, there is no saying that which side is highbred. vpn ckient

Anonymous said...

Along with many improvements in liposuction, laser lipo takes it one step further and offers increased skin tightening, less damage to the surrounding tissue during the procedure and in return, less downtime post procedure. For instance, in the event you smoke cigarettes, drink excessively, make use of pills, and so on, you are wearing intensely on your nervous feelings., the weather network bowmanville. Soon after finding a lawyer to handle the sale, you need to advise them to represent you throughout the entire operation. sql server beta 2

Anonymous said...

The buyer's conveyance lawyer should go through the contract and may possibly request more information or answers to certain concerns. Each companion activity guide lists age appropriate rules and activities for the game markings found in the blueprint., access network port. He had total disdain for anyone he was playing. remote exploits forum

Anonymous said...

Heya are using Wordpress for your blog platform? I'm new to the blog world but I'm trying to get started and set up my own.

Do you need any coding knowledge to make your own blog?
Any help would be really appreciated!

Here is my page; ford ranger

Anonymous said...

here on the official internet blog assembled a huge collection of interesting articles about [url=http://scypek.ru/skachat-skype.html]скайп скачать бесплатно русская версия[/url].

Anonymous said...

The articleice Machines introduces:This article about How To Buy Commercial Ice Machines For Restaurant,With the introduction of cutting edge and innovative technologies, a commercial ice machine is no longer a bulky device producing insanitation, consuming a lot ...

If you need more ice Machines infomation about How To Buy Commercial Ice Machines For Restaurant, Click here to find.

With the introduction of cutting ice Machines edge and innovative technologies, a commercial ice machine is no longer a bulky device producing insanitation, consuming a lot of energy, making noise, and taking a lot of time to make the needed supply of ice. As a result of high end technologies, commercial ice machines are able to achieve “being green” the highest levels of energy and water conservation. Now a commercial ice machine can easily produce from 65 pounds to 2,000 pounds of ice cubes in a day. You can find varied shapes of ice cubes such as dice, half dice, octagon, crushed, nugget, and flake.

Commercial ice machines are the standalone units,ice Machines designed to produce large quantities of ice for various commercial purposes. Once installed, these commercial ice makers are pretty automatic and do not need much attention from you or your staff. These factory-made machines consist of a condensing unit and ice-making section that operates as an integrated unit to make ice, an ice bin or a storage unit to store the created ice and a dispensing unit to dispense the ice out of the machine. Many automatic ice machines use moving water to create an improved quality of ice cubes. They work on the principle of “faster the water moves the better the ice quality becomes”. In this process, the air and un-dissolved solids get washed away. This results in pure and clear ice production.

Large amounts of ice are demanded for various purposes in many ice Machines commercial entities such as Restaurants, Bars, Ice Cream Parlors, Bakeries, Country Clubs and Golf Courses. A commercial ice machine is the perfect choice for such places as the large quantity of ice also needs to be a certain quality as well. Automatic commercial ice machines will make plenty of ice of equal size in a short span of time. All you need to do is just start the machine and set the required functions, and leave the rest up to the machine. You will get good quantity of quality ice in a short amount of time. In addition, many commercial ice machines come with a self cleaning function. This will help maintain the quality and quantity if the produced ice while decreasing the time that you and or your staff must spend with the machine.

Keep in mind that there are two varieties of ice machines: air cooled and waterice Machines cooled. Air cooled ice machines use air to disperse the heat, whereas water cooled ice machine uses water to do the same function. Air cooled ice machines use more energy and also are much noisier than water cooled ice machines. However, they are more affordable than water cooled ice machines.

An assorted collection of wonderful, fast and energy efficient commercial ice makers are readilyice Machines available in the market. Various renowned and reliable manufacturers have come up with their unique range of these amazing machines. Numerous models that create different types and sizes of ice are available in the local and online market. A competitive urge of creating more efficient and cost effective ice machines, has left the customers and consumers with a distinctive variety of these units in which to choose.

Anonymous said...

free dating bbw http://loveepicentre.com/faq/ scanna dating
russian dating scam online dating site [url=http://loveepicentre.com/success_stories/]australia online dating[/url] is lisa ann dating robert kardashian
who is justin beiber dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/contact/]text message dating book[/url] dating abbreviations [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/COOLMEN/]COOLMEN[/url] avay marie dating service

Anonymous said...

dating fender musicmaster bass http://loveepicentre.com/contact/ dating social networks
back leave sturgis dating online [url=http://loveepicentre.com]dating simulation for girls[/url] romance dating scam com
danish dating club [url=http://loveepicentre.com/contact/]are andrews and maksim chmerkovskiy dating[/url] free dating in lansing [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/intimateseeker/]intimateseeker[/url] 100 free south america dating site

Anonymous said...

thermoluminescence dating http://loveepicentre.com/ cutting dating expenses
hiv dating tulsa [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]single mother dating website[/url] african american speed dating
boise idaho dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/taketour/]on line dating email tips[/url] who is larry david dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/kazzycole/]kazzycole[/url] is ashley leggat dating

Olivia Princess said...

I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog.
انجام پایان نامه کارشناسی ارشد